House of Delegates Resolution 8
Establish a Committee to Study Allowing Oregon State Bar Members to Obtain Primary Malpractice Coverage from Private Insurers
Whereas, The Oregon State Bar Professional Liability Fund (PLF) currently holds a mandated statewide monopoly on primary malpractice insurance for all bar members; and
Whereas, Oregon is the only state in the entire country that requires attorneys to carry malpractice insurance as a condition of practicing law and it is also the only state in the country with a mandated monopoly insurance carrier; and
Whereas, This lack of competition allows a single entity to control prices and the terms of coverage, limiting options for Oregon attorneys; and
Whereas, PLF premiums are significantly higher, and the policy provisions are less comprehensive compared to what is available through private insurance markets; and
Whereas, Many attorneys, particularly solo practitioners and small law firms, are financially burdened by the high cost of PLF coverage, which may also limit their ability to grow their practices, serve their communities, and provide legal services to marginalized and underserved populations; and
Whereas, Allowing bar members to obtain malpractice insurance from private insurers—so long as the coverage is equal to or exceeds that provided by the PLF—will promote competition, potentially lowering premiums and improving the terms of coverage; therefore, be it
Resolved, that the Oregon State Bar shall establish a committee to explore and propose the feasibility of allowing bar members to obtain primary malpractice insurance from private insurers, provided that the coverage meets or exceeds the protections currently offered by the Oregon State Bar Professional Liability Fund (PLF).
The Oregon State Bar Professional Liability Fund (PLF) is the sole provider of primary malpractice insurance for Oregon attorneys, making Oregon the only state in the nation with a mandated monopoly provider. Furthermore, Oregon is the only state that requires all attorneys to carry malpractice insurance as a condition of practicing law. As a result, attorneys face higher premiums and fewer policy options compared to what is available through private insurers in other states. This lack of choice places a disproportionate financial burden on solo practitioners and small law firms, who typically have fewer resources to absorb these costs.
In all other aspects of their lives, Oregon lawyers benefit from having the ability to choose their insurance providers, whether for general business insurance, home insurance, car insurance, or even health insurance. This choice fosters competition, leading to better pricing and tailored policy options. By allowing Oregon attorneys to obtain malpractice insurance from private insurers—so long as it meets or exceeds the PLF’s coverage standards—competition can drive down prices and improve the terms of coverage, benefiting both attorneys and the clients they serve.
This resolution seeks the formation of a committee to study and propose the implementation of allowing bar members to obtain primary malpractice coverage from private insurers. Addressing this issue would enable the Oregon State Bar to reduce the financial burdens on Oregon attorneys, empowering them to better serve clients who face barriers to justice due to the high costs of legal services.
Financial Impact
This committee should be staffed with volunteers so as to minimize additional costs to the Bar. The Board of Governors anticipates there will be a budgetary impact based on additional staff time needed to support the volunteer workgroup.
Submitted by:
Mario Musil, OSB# 206766, HOD Region 7
Vote Percentages
Yes Votes: 28
|
No Votes: 98
|
Abstentions: 5
|
Vote Tally
Name |
Yes |
---|---|
Douglas Primmer | Yes |
Chase Beguin | Yes |
B Felder | Yes |
Ryan Collier | Yes |
Howard Newman | Yes |
Jon Rand | Yes |
Andrew Johnson | Yes |
Jeremiah Ross | Yes |
Kimberly Riley | Yes |
Mario Musil | Yes |
Michael Lowry | Yes |
Michael Purcell | Yes |
Andrea Madison | Yes |
Brian Gardner | Yes |
Christopher Piekarski | Yes |
Andrew Mittendorf | Yes |
Jeremy Bordelon | Yes |
Earl Christison | Yes |
Matthew Sutton | Yes |
Greg Raburn | Yes |
Samuel Imperati | Yes |
Whitney Stark | Yes |
Rachel Philips | Yes |
Daniel Evans | Yes |
Erin Christison | Yes |
Nicholas Lumley | Yes |
Sonya Fischer | Yes |
Sage Ertman | Yes |
Name |
No |
---|---|
Shane Davis | No |
Damien Munsinger | No |
Stephanie Brown | No |
Kellie Furr | No |
Kate Flanagan | No |
Lake James Perriguey | No |
Michelle Burrows | No |
Brent Smith | No |
John Grant | No |
Cody Berne | No |
Bradley Holbrook | No |
Myah Kehoe | No |
Kamron Graham | No |
Sonia Montalbano | No |
Nicholas Yanchar | No |
Scott Lucas | No |
John Bachofner | No |
Jennifer Kinzey | No |
Carl Mueller | No |
Kay Teague | No |
Brian Marshall | No |
John Marandas | No |
Curtis Peterson | No |
John Schlosser | No |
Amy Bingham | No |
Mike Truesdale | No |
Peter Werner | No |
Melissa Jaffe | No |
Maureen McGee | No |
Christopher Potts | No |
James Klonoski | No |
Jason Mitchell | No |
Michael Stevens | No |
Mark Johnson-Roberts | No |
Adam LeBrun | No |
Matthew McKean | No |
Clinton Williams | No |
Kevin Yolken | No |
Vanessa Nordyke | No |
Timothy Williams | No |
Victory Walker | No |
Trevor Byrd | No |
Kristie Gibson | No |
Shallon Martin | No |
David Wade | No |
Mia Getlin | No |
Christopher Morgan | No |
Aaron Reichenberger | No |
Christopher Rounds | No |
Eddie Medina | No |
Theresa Kohlhoff | No |
Michael Fuller | No |
Sara Foroshani | No |
Faith Morse | No |
Joshua Lay | No |
Thomas Flaherty | No |
Catherine Schulist | No |
Jason Posner | No |
Linda Degman | No |
Amber Labrecque | No |
Steve Milla | No |
Royce Williams | No |
Tomas Hernandez | No |
Leslie Nelson | No |
Brian Stimson | No |
Caleb Berthelsen | No |
Juhi Aggarwal | No |
David Robinson | No |
Joseph Walsh | No |
Micah Moskowitz | No |
Emet Klepper | No |
Kristen Farnworth | No |
Elizabeth Inayoshi | No |
Heather Decker | No |
Russell Garrett | No |
Laura Burgee | No |
Garrett Ramsey | No |
Xin Xu | No |
Jennifer Meisberger | No |
James Oberholtzer | No |
David Wu | No |
Hertsel Shadian | No |
Karen Moore | No |
John Devlin | No |
Theodore Reuter | No |
Shannon Flowers | No |
Laura Coffin | No |
Apolinar Montero-Sanchez | No |
Benjamin Haile | No |
Ryan Bickler | No |
Shawn Lillegren | No |
Joshua Gums | No |
Kyle Sciuchetti | No |
Emily Oberdorfer | No |
Bryan Boender | No |
Bradley Thayer | No |
Kathryn Clarke | No |
Eddie Passadore | No |
Name |
Abstain |
---|---|
Angela Engstrom | Abstain |
Cameron Tinker | Abstain |
Janae Bly | Abstain |
Travis Benn | Abstain |
Emil Ali | Abstain |